Cask vs keg comes down to where the beer finishes. Cask ale leaves the brewery with live yeast still in it, finishes conditioning in your cellar and goes out by hand pump with no added gas. Keg beer is finished at the brewery, often pasteurised, then pushed to the tap with gas. For the pub, the difference that costs money is time: Cask Marque's guidance is three days to sell a cask once it's on, and about five for a keg.

Most pages on this are written for drinkers, and they're fine for that. Behind the bar you need a different answer: which one wastes more, which one makes more per pint, and when a cask line is earning its place. So here's the side by side, then the sums.

Cask vs keg, side by side

The differences that matter in a pub (sources below)
CaskKeg
At the breweryLive yeast left in, so it keeps conditioningFinished at the brewery, often pasteurised, nothing left to condition
ConditioningFinishes in your cellar, a secondary fermentation in the cask. Up to three daysDone at the brewery. Rest it about 48 hours in the cellar before connecting
How it's servedHand pull (beer engine) or gravity, no added gasPushed by CO2 or a CO2 and nitrogen mix
TemperatureServed at cellar temperature, 11 to 13°CStored at 11 to 13°C, then chilled on the way to the tap
Once on saleSell within three daysSell within about five days
Standard containerFirkin, 72 pints (pins 36, kils 144)11-gallon or 50-litre, 88 pints
Sellable from a standard containerMid-60s from a firkin84 to 86 from 88
DutyThe same draught rate for both if under 8.5% and in a container of 20 litres or more: £19.45 per litre of pure alcohol now, £20.34 from 1 February 2027
Average pint£4.91 (cask)£4.89 standard lager, £5.94 premium lager

The duty row surprises people. A pin is 20.5 litres, so even the smallest common cask gets the draught rate. There's no tax reason to choose one over the other. The reasons are all in the cellar.

What "real ale" means

CAMRA coined the term in the 1970s for beer served from a cask without the injection of additional carbon dioxide: a living product, with brewers' yeast that carries on conditioning the beer in its container after filling. So cask ale is real ale. A standard keg lager pushed with gas isn't, whatever the pump clip says.

There's a newer middle ground worth knowing. CAMRA now uses "live beer" for the whole family of beers that keep conditioning in their final container, and that includes some cans, cellar tanks and membrane kegs. If a brewer offers you live beer in a membrane keg, that's what they mean: cask-style beer that keeps longer, served from a keg coupler.

Why cask wastes more of itself

A keg is sealed and sterile. You lose a couple of pints at changeover, the fob and the line end, and that's about it. A cask has sediment at the bottom by design, you pull some through every session to check it's in condition, and once it's been vented the clock is running whether you sell it or not. From the working figures in my pints in a keg guide:

Built-in loss per standard container (my working figures)
ContainerHoldsSellableBuilt-in loss
11-gallon keg8884 to 862 to 4.5%
Firkin72Mid-60sAbout 10%
Pin36About 30About 17%

That's before anything has gone wrong. Leave a firkin on for five days because the line's slow and you're pouring the last of it away, or worse, serving it.

What that does to your GP

Here's the sum I'd want every cask pub to do once. Say a firkin costs you £100 ex VAT, an illustrative round number; put your own in. At the £4.91 average cask pint, that's £4.09 once the VAT's out.

One firkin, two ways of costing it (illustrative £100 firkin, my arithmetic)
Costed on 72 pintsCosted on 65 sold
Cost per pint£1.39£1.54
GP at £4.91 (£4.09 ex VAT)66.0%62.4%

Nearly four points of GP between the price list and the cellar, on a pint that sells for about the same as a standard lager. That's why cask can look fine on the calculator and still drag a stocktake down. It's not missing beer. It's sediment, pull-through and the end of a cask that didn't sell in time. Price it off the second column.

The 22-a-day test

A cask line pays when it empties inside three days. Divide the sellable pints by three:

Pints a day each cask needs to sell to finish in three days (my arithmetic)
CaskSellablePints a day needed
PinAbout 3010
FirkinAbout 6522
KilderkinAbout 13043

Pull the last month off your till for each cask line and divide by the days you were open. Under 22 a day on firkins, either drop to pins, cut to fewer cask lines, or accept you're paying for the choice. Cask on-trade volumes were down 7.1% in the year to July 2026, so plenty of pubs have more handpulls than cask drinkers. The draught lines guide has what an under-used tap costs, and the keg life guide does the same sum for kegs.

So which makes more money?

Keg is safer. It keeps longer, wastes less and forgives a slow week. Cask makes good money when it sells fast, brings in people who'll travel for a decent pint, and costs nothing extra in duty. Where cask loses money is the third or fourth handpull nobody asked for.

My view: one cask line that's always fresh beats three that are tired. If you want variety, rotate a guest on one pump rather than adding pumps. And whatever you run, count it properly. In StockTap you set each cask by its size and count the open one by the pints on the dip rod, kegs by size and weight, so the sellable number is what the stocktake measures, not the 72 on the side. How to calibrate the dip rod is in the calibration guide, and how to vent and tap so you get the most out of each cask is in how to tap a cask.

What I'd do this week

Take your slowest cask line. Write the day it went on sale on the cask with chalk. If it's not empty by day three, that's your answer about that line, and no amount of arguing with the stocktaker will change it.

Common questions

What is the difference between cask and keg beer?

Cask ale still has live yeast, finishes its conditioning in the pub cellar and is served by hand pump without added gas. Keg beer is finished at the brewery, often pasteurised, and pushed to the tap with carbon dioxide or a carbon dioxide and nitrogen mix.

Is cask ale the same as real ale?

Yes. CAMRA coined real ale for beer served from a cask without the injection of additional carbon dioxide, with live yeast still conditioning it in the container. CAMRA now also uses the term live beer for beers that keep conditioning in other containers, including some cans, cellar tanks and membrane kegs.

How long does cask ale last compared with keg?

Cask Marque's guidance is to sell a cask within three days of putting it on sale and a keg within about five days. Cask also needs up to three days in the cellar to condition before it's ready.

Is there more profit in cask or keg?

Not automatically. The average cask pint is about the same price as a standard lager, but a firkin usually yields fewer sellable pints than it holds because of sediment and pulling through. On an illustrative £100 firkin, pricing off 65 sellable pints instead of 72 takes GP from about 66% to about 62%.

Do cask and keg pay the same duty?

Yes, if the beer is under 8.5% and in a container of 20 litres or more that connects to a pump or a gas tap. Both get the lower draught rate, currently £19.45 per litre of pure alcohol for beer from 3.5% to under 8.5%, rising to £20.34 on 1 February 2027.

Sources

  • Real ale served from a cask without the injection of additional carbon dioxide, a living product conditioning in its container, mass-market beers "artificially carbonated, often pasteurised", and live beer covering some cans, cellar tanks and membrane kegs: CAMRA, What is live beer?, checked 14 November 2026.
  • Keg sold within 5 days, cellar 11 to 13°C: Cask Marque, Beer quality issues, and cask sold within three days of going on sale: Cask Marque, Cask cellar card (PDF), both as cited in my keg life guide. Most cask ales take up to 3 days to condition: Cask Marque re-opening guide, as cited in my cask tapping guide. 48 hours in the cellar before connecting a keg: Tennent's Direct, Keg beer, as cited in the keg life guide.
  • Draught relief for containers that hold 20 litres or more and connect to a pump or gas tap, under 8.5% ABV: HMRC, Check if you can pay less Alcohol Duty on draught products. £19.45 draught rate now and £20.34 from 1 February 2027: my Budget 2026 guide.
  • Average cask pint £4.91 and on-trade cask volumes down 7.1%: The Morning Advertiser Beer Report 2026 and CGA by NIQ, 23 July 2026, as used in my cask ale pricing guide. Standard lager £4.89 and premium lager £5.94: Morning Advertiser pint price survey, May 2026, as used in my average pint price guide.
  • Container sizes and working sellable figures: my pints in a keg guide. The £100 firkin GP table and the pints-a-day test are my own illustrative arithmetic; use your own invoice price.